Making the case for a crisis in k12 education is not. The truth behind waiting for superman and the myth of. The lessons of waiting for superman ought to be considered by all those making decisions about education in america. I have seen my own children suffer as a result of poor teaching, though this has occurred as often in schools without union protections as those that were unionized. Nov 29, 2010 posts about waiting for superman written by jeremylenzi. As a teacher i found this book incredibly sad yet also wildly uplifting. It presents two options for parents to consider when sending their kids to school. This scene is extremely insightful and focuses on an ongoing controversy of teacher unions and how they are affecting urban students education. Waiting for superman the crisis in public education. The plight of poor children in underperforming schools, the silliness of the k12 tenure system, and the counterproductive effect of many teacher s unions ought to cause the people of the kingdom of god to ask the question, how. I have seen my own children benefit from excellent teachers over the. One important topic that the book talks about is the tenure system. Waiting for superman just antibad teachers sun sentinel.
The 12 most frustrating things i saw or didnt see watching waiting for superman. Waiting for superman decries tenure as a drag on teacher improvement. Oct 08, 2010 its a claim made by a charter school leader in the education documentary waiting for superman. It criticizes some public figures featured in waiting for superman, proposes different policies to improve education in the united states and counters the. Each of the kids was sympathetic, and they dramatized the deep inequality of opportunity in america. Dec 28, 2011 tenure is the backbone to waiting for superman s argument that teachers unions dont work, but in reality this slight setback cannot explain away decades of negligent within americas education. A collection of essays by different people with the central theme that teachers and. Guggenheim initially filmed a documentary in 1999 on teachers which showed that many teachers are heavily invested in the children they teach, coping.
Superman documentary draws praise, controversy education week. All tenure does is require due process according to contract rules mutually agreed to by unions and school boards. Daniel mitchoff while watching waiting for superman one thing becomes blatantly clear. The film, waiting for superman by davis guggenheim focuses on a key scene that is centered on the affects of teacher tenure and the teacher union contracts. Waiting for superman shows the struggles that administrators like geoffry canada and michelle rhee faced when trying to fire bad teachers, but were unable to because of the protection unions had given to tenured teachers.
Waiting for superman in 2010, waiting for superman was released. At the time, the union refused to put it to a vote. Heres what you see in waiting for superman, the new documentary that celebrates the charter school movement while blaming teachers. Administrators found they needed to trade bad teachers because its easier than getting rid of them. But unlike many of my colleagues, i think the film promotes just the kind of educational discourse this country so desperately needs right now. In essence, as the saying goes, winning a few battles does not necessarily mean we won the war. David guggenheim spent a lot more money on the movie than the research that went into the movie.
The march of the scapegoats the real issue is the quality of instruction. Rhee comments that tenure helps adults, but hurts the kids. If waiting for superman left you wanting to help teachers who dont have the same materials available to those in more affluent school systems, consider going to. The current system of tenure due process does get a few things wrong. Emily during the making of waiting for superman, emily is an eighthgrader in california who hopes to become a teacher one day. Tenure is the backbone to waiting for superman s argument that teachers unions dont work, but in reality this slight setback cannot explain away decades of negligent within americas education.
Waiting for superman is yet another book written about our failing schools. Reflecting on the title of the film, waiting for superman, educator geoffrey canada reveals, one of the. It is the companion guide to the documentary by davis guggenheim thats stirring up as much debate about public education as his earlier an. Oct 30, 2017 waiting for superman shows the struggles that administrators like geoffry canada and michelle rhee faced when trying to fire bad teachers, but were unable to because of the protection unions had given to tenured teachers. Teachers respond to waiting for superman mother jones. Whether you believe charter schools are the new superman, or. Produced by a major studio paramount, waiting for superman was released in washington, d. Despite that fact, i was granted tenure automatically. Waiting for superman was a documentary explaining the problems with the american education system.
Books that she has read in the library have helped her. Compelling soundbite to sell a movie maybe but when it comes to real education reform, nea president dennis van roekel gives the american public more credit than the backers of waiting for superman. This paper suggests the recent film waiting for superman offers an. Howard fuller, the superintendent of milwaukee public schools from 1991 to 1995, explains. Mar 12, 2011 one answer replaced into to place a paragraph on a decal and stick it interior the text fabric e book, and require that one and all instructors making use of the e book study the paragraph out loud to the youngsters. Posts about waiting for superman written by jeremylenzi. It does seem clear that the teachers unions and the farreaching tenure systems they support are a significant part of the problem. Is teacher tenure ruining the american education system. The protected, tenured teacher waiting to collect her pension is the reason why americas children dont have a highquality. May 25, 2011 yet instead of examining this critical issue objectively, the movie waiting for superman cites false statistics in their effort to scapegoat teachers, unfairly blaming them for all the failures of our urban schools.
Sing a song of six pants 1947 remastered hd 1080p duration. Here, despite its shortcomings, the film has hit the main clot blocking the blood flow to our childrens brains. I apologize for some sloppy math in not annualizing what was a six year rate in the apparent source article for the film. Tenured teachers cannot be fired without due process and a good reason. False data and fraudulent claims in response to critical comments, i have added clarifications and corrections in bold italics to my original post.
Be careful to include quotation marks and page numbers for all sources and to attach a works cited as well. A barrelchested comic book character must save public education. Waiting for superman is filled with disturbing statistics. Second, the film takes a healthy crack at teacher s unions. The film features the views of eric hanushek of the hoover institute, a wellknown conservative critic of equitable educational. The united states spends the more money per capita for education than any other country in the world, yet outcomes continue to fail. Apr 03, 2011 tenure on waiting for superman pittarjd1. I was granted tenure by the school district after 3 years and a day as any employee is. An examination of the current state of education in america today. You can troll through teacher wish lists from all over america and make a teachers dream come truewhether its books for a traveling library, or computers. Kipp schools, with no teacher tenure, have also implemented a certain teaching method that is mass producing kids who end up going all the way through college. The unions are also hurt by public frustration with teacher tenure, a level of job security inconceivable to most american workers, who are barely hanging on during a recession with a nearly 10 percent unemployment rate. I apologize for some sloppy math in not annualizing what was a six. With charles adam, charles adams, jonathan alter, robert balfanz.
The film is obviously biased against teachers unions and in favor of charter schools and other public school alternatives. I wanted to hate waiting for superman, i really did. One answer replaced into to place a paragraph on a decal and stick it interior the text fabric e book. The truth behind waiting for superman and the myth of teacher tenure 22 apr. I support a higher standard for teacher tenure and more rigorous teacher evaluation systems. Things such as the ease in which a public school teacher achieves tenure, the inability to fire a teacher who is.
Widerelease movies like waiting for superman and wont back down, funded by philanthropists who made their fortunes in the private sector, portray teacher tenure and its defender. Waiting for superman is brilliant it manipulates emotions, it takes facts. The problem teacher gets quietly passed along to someone else. However, i had not received the necessary official observations required of a nontenured teacher. Yeah, the basic premise of a failing school system with the united states is repeatedly emphasized within modern politics despite. Compelling soundbite to sell a movie maybe but when it comes to real education reform, nea president dennis van roekel gives the american public more credit than the backers of waiting for superman nowhere in the film or its discussion have teachers voices been heard, says van roekel. The teacher store book clubs book fairs scholastic education classroom magazines about us. Without a decent teacher, students will never receive a decent education. In waiting for superman, the 2010 documentary that describes the failure of american public education, several children and their families, along with educators like geoffrey canada and philanthropists like bill gates, drive home the argument that the key to school reform lies in improving the competence and skills of individual teachers. As a teacher who cares, gives multiple added hours, and is constantly trying to improve at my craft, you have made me.
Although this book was published in 2010, there has been no real change with the problems in our educational system. Mar 06, 2011 the lessons of waiting for superman ought to be considered by all those making decisions about education in america. She lives in an affluent neighborhood with schools that boast high graduation rates. Playing the nyc teacher tenure blame game cbs new york. Oct 05, 2010 neas waiting for superman resources a barrelchested comic book character must save public education. Its a claim made by a charter school leader in the education documentary waiting for superman.
The title for his latest documentary comes from an illustration given by geoffrey canada, founder to harlems childrens zone, who recalls that as a child his belief in a superman who could arrive on the scene and set things right was shattered by the reality that not everything can be fixed so simply and. Sep 24, 2010 waiting for superman is filled with disturbing statistics. Second, the film takes a healthy crack at teachers unions. In fact, i got caught up in what i was reading and expected to see 102 minutes of bashing teachers. As pointed out in the film, a bad teacher only covers 50 percent of the curriculum while a good one covers about 150 percent. Tenure laws are not intended to prevent dismissal of incompetent teachers, as superman wants us to believe. Davis guggenheims celebrated, controversial documentary waiting for superman takes a searching look at the hard realities of american public education today.
Waiting for, waiting for superman to tell the truth. Administrators have to show perseverance and weed out the low performing teachers before tenure. Waiting for superman also gives us hope when describing schools such as kipp schools and charter schools. Once teachers are granted tenure, they can be dismissed for specific reasons only, as provided by statute, such as incompetence, insubordination, or moral misconduct tenure not a lifetime job guarantee. Her local high school has golf and water polo teams, a stateoftheart drama theater and amazing test scores. Teacher tenure is an outdated, ridiculous notion that needs to be redesigned so that it is much harder to earn. As a tenured teacher in a public high school serving a lowincome community, my response to superman is mixed. The film, waiting for superman by davis guggenheim focuses on a key scene that is centered on the affects of teacher tenure and the teacher. Davis guggenheim directed the academy awardwinning 2006 film an inconvenient truth. The plight of poor children in underperforming schools, the silliness of the k12 tenure system, and the counterproductive effect of many teachers unions ought to cause the people of the kingdom of god to ask the question, how. His first book, teamsters, was released in 1978 and told the story of. In illinois, where one in 57 doctors loses his medical license and one in 97 lawyers loses his law license, only one in. I dont believe that this teacher should be able to hide behind tenure whatsoever, but i do believe in due process.
Waiting for superman paramount pictures meet the five unforgettable children featured in waiting for superman, a documentary that reveals the heartbreaking obstacles some kids must overcome so they can have what every child deserves. This attack on teachers was focused on teachers unions and the shortcomings of the tenure. For some reason, this was misunderstood in my last post. Waiting for superman is a 2010 american documentary film directed by davis guggenheim. Waiting for superman examines these questions and offers some answers some convincing, others less so. I would talk about how the last time i saw a movie that i hated more was the passion of the christ. Sep 27, 2010 waiting for superman decries tenure as a drag on teacher improvement. Waiting for superman is onedimensional in another important way. There is also a companion book titled waiting for superman.
Guggenheim initially filmed a documentary in 1999 on teachers which showed that many teachers are. Confronting educational politics with preservice teachers. Jun 10, 2016 waiting for superman also gives us hope when describing schools such as kipp schools and charter schools. This film is essentially an attack on teacher tenure and the antichild work rules that permeate every district in america. He collaborated with muhammad yunus on his bestseller creating a world without poverty and has edited two previous participant media guides, food, inc.
Michelle rhee discusses waiting for superman, charter schools and school vouchers duration. The filmmaker, david guggenheim and his team followed five children and their families throughout the country as they waited for the lottery to go to their chosen charter schools, to escape dropout factories aka, public schools. As a teacher who cares, gives multiple added hours, and is constantly trying to improve at my craft, you have made me feel like feel like a bottom feeder in metropolis. How did being a public school teacher become so controversial. In waiting for superman, director davis guggenheim explores how americas public school system is failing students and their families, resulting in tens of thousands of dropouts, while also contributing to the phenomena of failing neighbourhoods. In waiting for superman, michelle tries to break apart the notion of tenure with a new proposal that would allow washington, d.
Waiting for superman, which focuses on programs in five urban cities, is the. Thats what waiting for superman and this guide are about sparking the conversations and. If you only watch one movie this year, watch the documentary waiting for superman. Unions should take initiative and develop fair ways for administrators to do these evaluations. A teacherbacked group called the grassroots education movement produced a rebuttal documentary titled the inconvenient truth behind waiting for superman, which was released in 2011. Teacher tenure is detrimental to the education system, but whats ruining it is that the current generation has a very large contingent of aheads. Karl weber is a writer and editor based in new york. Apr 24, 2014 if waiting for superman left you wanting to help teachers who dont have the same materials available to those in more affluent school systems, consider going to. Armed with my notepad and accompanied by a fellow teacher, i bought my ticket. In trying to improve american public schools, educators, policymakers, and philanthropists are overselling the role of the highly skilled individual teacher and undervaluing the benefits that come from teacher collaborations that strengthen skills, competence, and a schools overall social capital. Administrators call it the dance of the lemons or passing the trash. There are statistics, illustrated by smart animation. In the waiting for superman companion book, guggenheim writes about his struggle, as a lifelong liberal, over how to present teachers unions in the film. Oct 15, 2010 all tenure does is require due process according to contract rules mutually agreed to by unions and school boards.
375 402 1402 97 357 115 822 511 1120 1197 1085 937 351 1437 728 1317 499 602 1219 1304 273 419 105 1376 877 254 479 608 390 726 639 467